Within Snippy
How Snippy Became a Flying Saucer Story
Changing headlines, unstable details and weakly documented claims transformed an unexplained carcass into a lasting UFO story.
On this page
- The first reports and the confused name
- How lights and ground marks entered the story
- What later investigations weakened or rejected
Page outline Jump by section
Introduction
The death of a horse near Alamosa, Colorado, in September 1967 became famous not because anyone saw a UFO attack it, but because a series of newspaper stories, retellings and embellishments gradually transformed an unexplained animal death into one of the most influential UFO legends in American history. The case helped establish a pattern that would later dominate animal-mutilation folklore: unusual carcass conditions, reports of strange lights, alleged physical traces on the ground and speculation that grew faster than the available evidence. By the time the story spread nationwide, many readers encountered it not as a puzzling livestock death but as a dramatic “flying saucer” mystery.[Denver Public Library]history.denverlibrary.orgufos and horse called snippyDenver Public LibraryUFOs and a Horse Called Snippy20 Oct 2020 — This odd tale formed the impetus for Linda Mouton Howe's seminal work, "…
Within Colorado’s UFO history, the importance of the Snippy case lies less in what happened to the horse and more in how reporting shaped public understanding. The episode shows how uncertain observations, repeated headlines and changing details can create a lasting legend even when later investigations find little support for the most extraordinary claims.[Denver Public Library]history.denverlibrary.orgufos and horse called snippyDenver Public LibraryUFOs and a Horse Called Snippy20 Oct 2020 — This odd tale formed the impetus for Linda Mouton Howe's seminal work, "…
The First Reports and the Confused Name
One of the earliest signs that the story was changing as it spread was the horse’s name. The animal was actually a mare called Lady, but newspapers across the United States repeatedly identified her as “Snippy”. Snippy was reportedly the name of her sire, yet the mistaken name became permanently attached to the case and remains the version most people recognise today.[denverlibrary.org]history.denverlibrary.orgufos and horse called snippyDenver Public LibraryUFOs and a Horse Called Snippy20 Oct 2020 — This odd tale formed the impetus for Linda Mouton Howe's seminal work, "…
The first nationally distributed stories appeared in early October 1967, nearly a month after the horse was found. Headlines emphasised mystery and possible flying saucer involvement. Sensational wording encouraged readers to view the case through a UFO lens before any formal investigation had reached conclusions. Reports highlighted apparently bloodless remains, smooth cuts, missing flesh and a lack of tracks around the carcass. These details were often presented as established facts rather than observations that might have alternative explanations.[Wikipedia]WikipediaMutilation of "Snippy" the horseMutilation of "Snippy" the horse
As newspapers copied and condensed each other’s reporting, the story became increasingly standardised. Readers in different states encountered similar dramatic claims, while uncertainties and contradictions received much less attention. The result was a powerful narrative: a healthy horse found mutilated under circumstances that supposedly defied normal explanation.[Wikipedia]WikipediaMutilation of "Snippy" the horseMutilation of "Snippy" the horse
How Lights and Ground Marks Entered the Story
A crucial shift occurred when reports about the carcass became linked to separate stories about unusual lights in the San Luis Valley. No witness reported seeing a UFO attack the horse. Instead, the UFO connection emerged by association. Accounts circulated that strange aerial objects had been seen in the region around the same period, and one elderly witness recalled a large object passing overhead, though she could not identify it. Over time, these separate elements were woven together into a single narrative.[Denver Public Library]history.denverlibrary.orgufos and horse called snippyDenver Public LibraryUFOs and a Horse Called Snippy20 Oct 2020 — This odd tale formed the impetus for Linda Mouton Howe's seminal work, "…
The story grew further when descriptions of the site itself became more elaborate. Reports mentioned:
- Circular marks on the ground interpreted as possible landing traces.
- Flattened bushes or vegetation.[facebook.com]facebook.comSource details in endnotes.
- Small depressions described as resembling landing-gear impressions.
- Allegedly elevated radiation readings.[facebook.com]facebook.comSource details in endnotes.
- A sweet or medicinal odour around the carcass.[Wikipedia]WikipediaMutilation of "Snippy" the horseMutilation of "Snippy" the horse
These claims became central to later retellings because they appeared to provide physical evidence rather than mere speculation. Yet many were poorly documented. The reported radiation readings were not accompanied by detailed measurement records. The ground marks were not shown to have been created at the same time as the horse’s death. The alleged landing traces were interpreted through a UFO framework rather than demonstrated to be connected to an aircraft or unknown object.[Denver Public Library]history.denverlibrary.orgufos and horse called snippyDenver Public LibraryUFOs and a Horse Called Snippy20 Oct 2020 — This odd tale formed the impetus for Linda Mouton Howe's seminal work, "…
The process resembles other famous UFO cases in which ordinary or ambiguous features of a landscape acquire significance once observers begin looking for evidence of a landing. In the Snippy case, the physical traces became more important in later retellings than they appear to have been in the earliest stages of the investigation.[Denver Public Library]history.denverlibrary.orgufos and horse called snippyDenver Public LibraryUFOs and a Horse Called Snippy20 Oct 2020 — This odd tale formed the impetus for Linda Mouton Howe's seminal work, "…
Why the Story Spread So Widely
The timing helped turn the case into a national phenomenon. The late 1960s were a period of intense public interest in flying saucers, and stories that combined UFOs with apparent physical evidence attracted substantial attention. The Snippy reports offered something unusual: not merely a sighting in the sky but a tangible object that people could visit and photograph.[Wikipedia]WikipediaMutilation of "Snippy" the horseMutilation of "Snippy" the horse
The case also introduced a theme that would become highly influential in later decades. Before Snippy, UFO reports usually focused on lights, craft or witness encounters. After Snippy, the idea that mysterious animal deaths might be linked to UFOs entered popular culture. Later waves of reported livestock mutilations in the 1970s were frequently compared with the Colorado case, making it a foundational story in the development of mutilation folklore.[Our Strange Planet]ourstrangeplanet.comOur Strange Planet50-Year Anniversary of the Snippy Case13 Sept 2017 — The horse probably died (or was killed) and disfigured on the nigh…
Authors, UFO researchers and paranormal writers helped keep the story alive long after the original event. Each retelling reinforced certain dramatic features while often omitting the uncertainties surrounding them. Through repetition, the case acquired the status of a classic UFO mystery even though the original evidence remained disputed.[Wikipedia]WikipediaMutilation of "Snippy" the horseMutilation of "Snippy" the horse
What Later Investigations Weakened or Rejected
The strongest challenge to the legend came from later investigations that examined the available evidence more critically. Researchers associated with the University of Colorado’s UFO study, commonly known as the Condon Committee, reviewed the case and concluded that there was no evidence linking the horse’s death to abnormal or extraterrestrial causes. Investigators found no reliable support for claims that a UFO had been involved.[Wikipedia]WikipediaMutilation of "Snippy" the horseMutilation of "Snippy" the horse
Subsequent assessments also questioned several elements that had become staples of the legend. The apparently precise removal of tissue could be explained by natural decomposition and scavenging processes. Claims about radiation and landing marks lacked adequate documentation. The absence of direct evidence connecting reported lights to the horse remained a major weakness. Most importantly, no witness ever observed a UFO interacting with the animal.[Denver Public Library]history.denverlibrary.orgufos and horse called snippyDenver Public LibraryUFOs and a Horse Called Snippy20 Oct 2020 — This odd tale formed the impetus for Linda Mouton Howe's seminal work, "…
Some later reports introduced additional complications. Accounts emerged suggesting the horse may have suffered a gunshot wound, while other details in the story shifted over time. These changing narratives highlighted how unstable the evidential record had become. Rather than strengthening the UFO interpretation, later scrutiny often revealed how much of the legend depended on repeated claims that were difficult to verify.[Wikipedia]WikipediaMutilation of "Snippy" the horseMutilation of "Snippy" the horse
How a Mystery Became a Legend
The enduring significance of Snippy in Colorado UFO history is not that investigators uncovered evidence of alien activity. Instead, the case demonstrates how folklore develops. A dead horse, unusual carcass conditions, local stories about strange lights and a series of dramatic newspaper reports combined to create a narrative far more powerful than the underlying evidence.[Denver Public Library]history.denverlibrary.orgufos and horse called snippyDenver Public LibraryUFOs and a Horse Called Snippy20 Oct 2020 — This odd tale formed the impetus for Linda Mouton Howe's seminal work, "…
As the story travelled, details became simplified, repeated and sometimes altered. The mistaken name “Snippy” replaced Lady. Ground marks became possible landing traces. Local light reports became part of the same event. Unverified claims gained authority through repetition. By the 1970s, the case had become a template for interpreting later animal mutilation reports through a UFO framework.[wikipedia.org]WikipediaMutilation of "Snippy" the horseMutilation of "Snippy" the horse
For readers exploring Colorado’s UFO history, the Snippy episode is therefore less a story about a proven unexplained event than a case study in legend-making. It shows how media coverage can elevate an ambiguous incident into a cultural landmark, and how later investigations may struggle to catch up once a compelling narrative has already taken hold.[Denver Public Library]history.denverlibrary.orgufos and horse called snippyDenver Public LibraryUFOs and a Horse Called Snippy20 Oct 2020 — This odd tale formed the impetus for Linda Mouton Howe's seminal work, "…
Amazon book picks
Further Reading
Books and field guides related to How Snippy Became a Flying Saucer Story. Use these as the next step if you want deeper reading beyond the article.
The Mysterious Valley
Examines the folklore and reporting environment surrounding the case.
The UFO Experience: A Scientific Inquiry
Provides a framework for separating evidence from narrative growth.
eBay marketplace picks
Marketplace Samples
Live-tested eBay searches with available results related to this page.
Selected fromalien t shirt oneBay.co.uk.
Endnotes
1.
Source: Wikipedia
Title: Mutilation of “Snippy” the horse
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutilation_of_%22Snippy%22_the_horse
2.
Source: Wikipedia
Title: Cattle mutilation
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cattle_mutilation
3.
Source: history.denverlibrary.org
Title: ufos and horse called snippy
Link:https://history.denverlibrary.org/news/western-history/ufos-and-horse-called-snippy
Source snippet
Denver Public LibraryUFOs and a Horse Called Snippy20 Oct 2020 — This odd tale formed the impetus for Linda Mouton Howe's seminal work, "...
4.
Source: coloradolifemagazine.com
Link:https://www.coloradolifemagazine.com/blog/post/the-legend-of-snippy-the-horse?srsltid=AfmBOooiuUzVVPMNyJsDT_K3VFdLGg-72XIGSmYMIw2ZkSUrO599Bt_K
Source snippet
The Saga of SnippyOriginally named Lady, the horse belonged to Nellie Lewis of Alamosa. She had spent three peaceful years on Lewis' brot...
5.
Source: ourstrangeplanet.com
Link:https://www.ourstrangeplanet.com/50-year-anniversary-of-the-snippy-case/
Source snippet
Our Strange Planet50-Year Anniversary of the Snippy Case13 Sept 2017 — The horse probably died (or was killed) and disfigured on the nigh...
6.
Source: coloradolifemagazine.com
Title: the legend of snippy the horse
Link:https://www.coloradolifemagazine.com/blog/post/the-legend-of-snippy-the-horse?srsltid=AfmBOopGgIV6jUD2mIdpCblcN0gBFGOuOeu5V1LBYnaNejtxWRJzeMIR
Source snippet
The Saga of SnippySnippy, the Appaloosa mare whose mysterious 1967 death fueled UFO lore, now rests at Snippy didn't become a legend beca...
Additional References
7.
Source: gazette.com
Link:https://gazette.com/2022/05/22/ufo-legend-horse-found-dead-and-mutilated-55-years-ago-in-colorado-gets-new-life-at-roadside-attraction-130b0e6c-ca4a-11ec-af09-ffeb7d7ab0f4/
Source snippet
UFO legend: Horse found dead and mutilated 55 years ago...22 May 2022 — Analyzing the mysterious corpse of the horse that came to be kno...
Published: May 2022
8.
Source: denvergazette.com
Title: The attraction is becoming home to the remains of Snippy the horse.Read more
Link:https://www.denvergazette.com/2022/05/22/ufo-legend-horse-found-dead-and-mutilated-55-years-ago-in-colorado-gets-new-life-at-roadside-attraction-d1f47242-c05f-5cbd-9230-7d1f1bd6f87b/
Source snippet
UFO legend: Horse found dead and mutilated 55 years ago...22 May 2022 — Alien statues stand in the vortexes garden outside the UFO Watch...
Published: May 2022
9.
Source: youtube.com
Title: Snippy the Horse: First Animal Mutilation UFO Case
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ryEktN2CVA
Source snippet
Roadside Colorado: The [UFO Watchtower]({{ 'ufo-watchtower/' | relative_url }}) & Snippy the Horse...
10.
Source: youtube.com
Title: Roadside Colorado: The UFO Watchtower & Snippy the Horse
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U-l3cKx0K1Y
Source snippet
Snippy the Horse Mutilation Incident Explained...
11.
Source: instagram.com
Link:https://www.instagram.com/p/CgVbUPUM4V4/?hl=en
12.
Source: reddit.com
Link:https://www.reddit.com/r/UnsolvedMysteries/comments/1fug68c/netflix_vol_5_episode_3_mysterious_mutilations/
13.
Source: instagram.com
Link:https://www.instagram.com/reel/DQfm9rcjOUk/
14.
Source: amazon.de
Link:https://www.amazon.de/Snippy-Horse-Mutilations-Cover-Up-Colorados/dp/B0G64VNDPP?tag=searcht-20
15.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/groups/6290323784427787/posts/25650118921354984/
16.
Source: denvergazette.com
Link:https://www.denvergazette.com/2021/11/24/looking-back-ufo-blamed-for-horse-mutilation-in-colorado-3011fe21-575b-5545-a2b6-7d5ef9c93601/